The long and worthy fight over the Keystone XL tar sands pipeline is at an end, and the time for a decision draws near. We appreciate your veto of the congressional bill, and we fully support an outright rejection of the permit. We have followed the question of Keystone XL’s impact for many years, and those years have clarified a few key points.
First, most of those who care about this project oppose it, and with an intensity matched by few issues in recent time.
Beginning with Tribal Nations and with farmers and ranchers, the opposition spread over time to climate scientists, college students, moms, financial experts, many trade unionists, renewable energy proponents, nurses, artists and an ever-growing swath of the general population. A historic number of them were arrested for this cause; millions wrote public comments, or emailed their elected officials; everyone engaged in public dialogue in precisely the fashion you have asked. Everyday people have stood up to the money on the other side, and done so with civility, firmness, creativity and passion.
Second, it’s now clearer than ever that the tar sands pose an incredible risk to the health and safety of our families and a livable planet.
As a major study in Nature last month confirmed, a serious effort to control global warming must keep the ‘dirtiest oil in the world’ safely underground. Keystone XL must be evaluated not just as a pipeline but as part of the tar sands industry’s plans for rapid and reckless expansion. As you have stated, the climate impacts of major infrastructure projects are a matter of national — and international — interest. Rejecting Keystone XL is the kind of principled choice leaders need to make. There is no way to reconcile this pipeline with a serious climate policy.
Third, the arguments for this pipeline — never strong — have disappeared on closer examination.
It is not a potent job-creating tool, nor a route to American energy independence; tar sands expansion is not inevitable; and the sheer number of leaks and spills means a tar sands pipeline would pose a clear danger to public health. It is, instead, a classic boondoggle, whose only beneficiaries will be a handful of rich oil companies while our families take on all the risk.
Many of the choices that define a presidency come by accident or chance — some storm or crisis that demands a quick response. But this one is firmly in your control. Climate change will be a defining issue of this century. Rejecting the Keystone XL pipeline will powerfully demonstrate your commitment to stopping the rising of the oceans, set the stage for further climate action and build a legacy worth sharing.
Willie Nelson, Musician
Mark Ruffalo, Actor
Neil Young, Musician
U.S. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse
Julianne Moore, Actress
Naomi Klein, Author
Alec Baldwin, Actor
U.S. Congressman Raul Grijalva
Robert Redford, Actor
Norman and Lyn Lear, Producers
Robert Reich, former U.S. Secretary of Labor
Rev. Jim Wallis, Preacher
Tom Goldtooth, Indigenous Environmental Network
Bill McKibben, 350.org
Jane Kleeb, Bold Nebraska
Thom Yorke, Musician
Michael Brune, Sierra Club
Melina Laboucan-Massimo, Lubicon Cree First Nation
James Hansen, Climate Scientist
Randy Thompson, Nebraska Rancher
Daryl Hannah, Actress
Jean Ross, Karen Higgins, Deborah Burger, National Nurses United
Faith Spotted Eagle, Ihanktonwan Treaty Council
Vanessa Redgrave, Actress
Larry Hanley, Amalgamated Transit Union
Michael Kieschnick, CREDO
Susan Sarandon, Actress
Lance Bass, Musician
Gene Karpinski, League of Conservation Voters
Van Jones, Author
Anna Galland, MoveOn.org
Robert Kennedy Jr., Author
Sarah Neufeld, Musician
Ian Somerhalder, Actor
Peter Lehner, Natural Resources Defense Council
Patti Smith, Musician
Mike Richter, Athlete
Frank Waln, Musician
Rev. Lennox Yearwood, Hip Hop Caucus
Marisa Tomei, Actress
John McEnroe, Athlete
Whit Jones and Kendall Mackey, Energy Action Coalition
Steve Kretzmann, Oil Change International
Arturo Carmona, Presente.org
Rebecca Solnit, Author
Laura Poitras, Film Director
Erich Pica, Friends of the Earth
Kyra Sedgwick, Actress
Todd Paglia, ForestEthics
Art and Helen Tanderup, Harvest the Hope Hosts
Josh Fox, Film Director
Ricken Patel, Avaaz.org
Thurston Moore, Musician
Fred Krupp, Environmental Defense Fund
Frank James, Dakota Rural Action
Dan Cantor, Working Families Party
Gus Speth, Environmentalist
Lindsey Allen, Rainforest Action Network
Taren Stinebrickner-Kauffman, SumOfUs
Richard Patrick, Musician
Margot Kidder, Actress
Ai-jen Poo, National Domestic Workers Alliance
Frances Fisher, Actress
Susan Stephenson, Interfaith Power and Light
Laura Michalchyshyn, Producer
Anthony Edwards, Actor
Jeremy Hays, Green For All
David Gelber, Producer
Steve Jordan, Musician
Billy Wimsatt, Author
Joel Bach, Producer
Joe Uehlein, Labor Network for Sustainability
Lyn Lear, Producer
Heather McGhee, Demos
Nebraska State Senator Ken Haar
Jonathan Marc Sherman, Playwright
Greg and Suzanne Walmer, Landowners
Fletcher Harper, Green Faith
Lonnie and Sandra Breiner, Landowners
Jack Geiger, Physicians for Human Rights
Martha Plimpton, Actress
Jack and Lynelle Huck, Landowners
Lloyd, Vencille, Paul, Cody and Logan Hipke, Landowners
Gary and Donna Roller, Landowners
Judy Sheridan-Gonzalez, New York State Nurses Association
Mike and Cheri Blocher, Landowners
Terry Tempest Williams, Author
Tom, Cathie, Lance Genung, Landowners
Annie Leonard, Greenpeace USA
William and Susan Huwaldt, Landowners
Barbara Kopple, Film Director
Wendy Abrams, Philanthropist
Kent Adelson, Landowner
Sherry Loseke, Landowner
John Quigley, Artist
Rebecca Foon, Musician
Lori and Ron Fischer, Landowners
Deepak Bhargava, Center for Community Change
John, Ty and Andrew Pribramsky, Landowners
Debbie Levin, Environmental Media Association
Joslyn Barnes, Producer
Kurt and Laura Meusch, Landowners
Walton Ford, Artist
Gerald and Vanessa Brand, Landowners
George Goehl, National People’s Action
Bob Holman, Poet
Larry, Lori and J.D. Mudloff, Landowners
John Cavanagh, Institute for Policy Studies
Shannon and Suz Straka-Heyden, Landowners
Alexandra Shiva, Film Director
Allpress Family, Landowners
Dr. Irwin Redlener, Children’s Health Fund
Delwyn and Allene K Schwager, Landowners
Jesse Paris Smith, Musician
Kimi Hendricks, Landowner
Scott Reed, PICO National Network
Ken Winston, Nebraska Sierra Club
Anne Waldman, Author
Aldo Seoane, Wica Agli
Laurie Anderson, Musician
Atossa Soltani, Amazon Watch
Lynn Goldsmith, Photographer
Terre Roche, Musician
Karen Sheinheit, Actress
Mark Ephraim, Producer
Larry and Ann Anderson, Landowners
Kim Pokorosky, Actress
Jim Doble, Musician
Alystyre Julian, Producer
Nacho Arimany, Musician
Mary Jane Nyberg, Landowners
Kate Sekules, Author
Hammond Family, Landowners
Devin Waldman, Musician
Abbi Kleinschmidt, Landowner
Bob Thurman, Author
Harrington Family, Landowners
Sam Messer, Artist
Ambrose Bye, Musician
Berry Family, Landowners
Eli Smith, Musician
Heather White, Environmental Working Group
Julie Panebianco, Musician
Kenny Bruno, New Venture Fund
Robert Kenner, Filmmaker
Sandy Newman, Voices for Progress